One Two
You are here: Home Seminars 08.05. BGSE Workshop: Benny Moldovanu

08.05. BGSE Workshop: Benny Moldovanu

BGSE Workshop with Benny Moldovanu (University of Bonn)

Event details
  • BGSE Workshop
When May 08, 2019
from 16:30 to 17:45
Where room 0.017
Contact Name Stephan Lauermann
Contact Email
Add event to calendar vCal


 The Art of Compromising: Voting with Interdependent Values and the Flag of the Weimar Republic 



We model a situation where ex ante opinions in a legislature are dichotomous but cross traditional left-right party lines, e.g., crucial decisions on ethical issues such as gay marriage and abortion, or joining/exiting an economic/political union. In addition to the two "extreme" positions on the left and on the right, we consider the effect of a compromise alternative whose location may be endogenous. We compare sequential, binary voting schemes conducted by privately informed agents 
with interdependent preferences: the voting process gradually reveals and aggregates relevant information about the location of preferred alternatives. The Anglo-Saxon amendment procedure (AV) always selects the (complete-information) Condorcet winner. In contrast, the continental successive procedure (SV) does not. This holds because AV allows learning about the preferences of both leftists and rightists,

while SV only allows one-directional learning at each step. Moreover,

under SV, the agenda that puts the alternative with ex ante higher support last elects the Condorcet winner more often than the agenda that puts that alternative first. The optimal compromise location for various goals is also shown to differ across voting procedures. We illustrate our main findings with a fascinating historical episode, the vote on the flag of the Weimar republic.


filed under:
Document Actions